Navigating the evolving world of creative writing: Insights from Anthony Bidulka

Author Anthony Bidulka

In a recent episode of the On Creative Writing podcast, listeners were treated to a deep dive into the craft and business of writing with award-winning mystery and suspense author Anthony Bidulka.

Anthony took a seat behind the mic to host this audio essay and shared his eveolution as a writer, along with lessons leraned from two decades in the publishing industry.

Key takeaways

• Clarify your motivation to sustain your writing journey.

• Navigating the evolving world of creative writing.

• Prioritize authentic character development and representation.

• Experiment with story structure to deepen your narrative.

• Find your unique writing process—and let it evolve.

• Embrace change as a sign of growth, not failure.

Understanding tour motivation: The writer’s compass

Anthony opens with a fundamental question: “Why do I write?” This isn’t just a philosophical musing—it’s a practical tool for navigating the inevitable challenges of a writing career.

Why motivation matters

• Sustains You Through Rejection: The publishing world is competitive and often discouraging. A clear sense of purpose helps you persist.

• Guides Creative Choices: Knowing your “why” shapes the stories you tell, the characters you create, and the themes you explore.

• Evolves With You: Your motivation may shift over time. Anthony’s own journey moved from telling stories about underrepresented places to focusing on underrepresented people.

  
  

Actionable advice

• Reflect regularly: Set aside time each year to revisit your motivations. Are you writing to entertain, to advocate, to process personal experiences, or to give voice to the unheard?

• Write a mission statement: Even a few sentences can clarify your purpose and keep you focused.

• Let your ‘Why’ guide your ‘What’: Choose projects and genres that align with your core motivation, not just market trends.

Navigating the evolving world of creative writing

Anthony’s career spans a period of dramatic change in publishing—from the rise of e-books to the decline of independent bookstores. His advice: expect the unexpected and stay flexible.

Key industry shifts

• Digital Revolution: E-books and audiobooks have transformed how readers access stories.

• Distribution Changes: The closure of many indie bookstores and the dominance of online retailers have altered how books reach audiences.

• Diversity and Representation: There’s a growing demand for stories from marginalized voices.

  
  

Actionable advice

• Stay informed: Follow industry news (e.g., Publishers Weekly, The Bookseller) to anticipate changes.

• Diversify your platforms: Don’t rely on a single format or retailer. Consider print, digital, and audio; explore both traditional and self-publishing.

• Network and collaborate: Engage with other writers, editors, and industry professionals to share insights and opportunities.

• Be willing to pivot: If a strategy or genre isn’t working, don’t be afraid to try something new.

Crafting authentic characters: The creation of Merry Bell

One of the episode’s highlights is Anthony’s discussion of Mary Bell, a transgender private investigator at the heart of his latest trilogy. Her story is both a compelling mystery and a nuanced exploration of identity.

Why representation matters

• Reflects real-world diversity: Readers want to see themselves and their communities in fiction.

• Builds empathy: Well-drawn characters from underrepresented backgrounds foster understanding and connection.

• Challenges stereotypes: Authentic portrayals move beyond clichés and tokenism.

  
  

Actionable advice

• Do your research: If writing outside your lived experience, consult with members of the community you’re representing.

• Focus on humanity: Don’t reduce characters to their identity markers. Mary Bell is a complex person—her gender identity is part of her, but not her whole story.

• Show, don’t tell: Let character traits and struggles emerge naturally through action and dialogue, not exposition.
  

Structuring your story: Lessons from Home Fires Burn

Anthony’s latest novel, Home Fires Burn, uses a dual-prologue structure to weave together personal and plot-driven storylines. This approach deepens both the mystery and the emotional stakes.

The power of structure

• Multiple perspectives: Two prologues introduce different threads—a man in crisis and Mary’s family struggles—setting up a rich, interconnected narrative.

• Foreshadowing and suspense: Early glimpses of key events or emotions hook readers and build anticipation.

• Character-driven plot: The mystery is inseparable from Mary’s personal journey, making the stakes more meaningful.

  
  

Actionable advice

• Experiment with structure: Don’t be afraid to break from traditional formats if it serves your story.

• Outline intersections: Map out how different storylines will converge. This ensures cohesion and payoff.

• Balance plot and character: Ensure that personal arcs and external conflicts are both given weight.

  
  

Plotting vs. pantsing: Finding your process

Anthony identifies as a plotter—he creates detailed outlines and planning documents before drafting. However, he acknowledges that every writer’s process is unique.

Plotting: The pros

• Reduces writer’s block: A roadmap keeps you moving forward.

• Ensures cohesion: Complex mysteries benefit from careful planning.

• Allows for flexibility: Outlines can be adjusted as new ideas emerge.
  

Pantsing: The pros

• Encourages discovery: Surprising yourself can lead to fresh, organic storytelling.

• Fosters creativity: Less structure can free your imagination.

Actionable advice

• Try both approaches: Experiment to find what works for you. Many writers blend plotting and pantsing.

• Use tools: Consider software like Scrivener, Notion, or even simple spreadsheets for outlining.

• Leave room for spontaneity: Even plotters should allow characters and stories to evolve during drafting.
  

Embracing change as you grow as a writer

Anthony’s career is a testament to the value of evolution. He started with literary suspense but found his voice in the mystery genre. He encourages writers to remain open to change.

Why flexibility matters

• Personal growth: Your interests and skills will develop over time.

• Market shifts: Reader preferences and industry trends are always in flux.

• Creative renewal: Trying new genres or styles can reignite your passion.
  

Actionable advice

• Regularly assess your goals: Are you still excited by your current projects? If not, explore new directions.

• Seek feedback: Beta readers, critique partners, and editors can help you identify strengths and areas for growth.

• Celebrate evolution: Don’t see change as failure—see it as progress.

Evolving as a writer is ongoing if you work at it

Anthony’s insights remind us that writing is both an art and a lifelong learning process. By understanding your motivation, adapting to industry changes, crafting authentic characters, experimenting with structure, refining your process, and embracing evolution, you can thrive in the ever-shifting world of creative writing.

Want to learn more? Connect with Anthony on his website and social media.